Via MangaBlog - which I highly suggest you subscribe to if you have more than a passing interest in Japanese comics but don’t want to spend all day reading and aggregating news and reviews from all over the entire interweb like tireless author Brigid Alverson seems to do - comes this new interview with Kurt Hassler at Publisher’s Weekly. To back up a bit, it was announced a few weeks ago that Yen Press would be taking the Maximum Ride/Twilight formula of bringing a Korean artist on board to create a comic serialization of a popular American young adult novel and apply it to Daniel X, another book series by Max Ride scribe James Patterson about a teenaged alien-hunter. (I believe there was actually an advertisement for it in the December issue, but I’m away from home for the holiday and can’t confirm that at the moment.) I didn’t post anything about it at the time because it’s not directly Yen Plus related and I don’t think it’s as big as the Twilight announcement, but it looks like, according to Mr Hassler, Daniel X will in fact be appearing in Yen Plus in one way or another:
Both Daniel X books will be adapted by Korean artist Seung-hye Kye and will appear in Yen Press’s manga anthology magazine, Yen Plus. However, Hassler commented that he did not know whether the Daniel X adaptation would appear in the magazine as a full serialization or a preview.
I’m kind of surprised that hasn’t been decided yet - seems like a rather vital detail to me. Perhaps two serializations of young adult novels by James Patterson about supernatural teenagers would be one too many. Anyway, the interview also mentions that Nightschool has been extended; originally intended for three volumes, it will now see a fourth. The article closes by mentioning Yen Plus’s open submissions policy, mentioning that apparently many submissions are rejected for being too derivative:
“We want to see artists develop their own voice, not mimic what they’ve read. We want to see artists tell something closer to home for them,” said Hassler. “It’s the necessary step for establishing the market here.”
I imagine that Hassler may have something like Prom Night in mind here. Though it wasn’t a favorite of mine, it was notable for its un-manga-ness, both in terms of plot and art style, in a magazine which is otherwise seething in it. I hope that up-and-coming comic creators who would think they wouldn’t have a chance in Yen Plus because their creations are not typical manga-style fare will take note and get their submissions in.
Tangentially related… From the same post at MangaBlog comes the tale of some back-and-forth on the subject of manhwa, or Korean comics; Daniella Orihuela-Gruber complains that most manhwa strikes her as shallow and with characters prone to petty bickering (the sample of Goong which ran in Yen Plus earlier this year exemplified those traits, I think), but a Korean American comics fan going by the name Tari responds, saying Orihuela-Gruber’s sample is tainted by the rather limited selection of manhwa available on the market, and that that sample is not representative of the most popular or best-selling domestic comics in Korea at all.
I think both writers make valid points. But it reminds me that Yen Press doesn’t really seem to use the word “manhwa” much, despite currently having the widest range of these products on the American market, as far as I know. Marketing for Max Ride describes it as a “manga,” as has its decidedly Korean scribe NaRae Lee, at least in translation. (Svetlana Chmakova of Nightschool also calls her work “manga,” for that matter). It raises the age-old question; what do words like “manga,” “manhwa” and “manhua” (the Chinese equivalent) mean? Are they convenient words to refer to comics originating from a certain geographical location, or comics of a certain artistic style regardless of geography? I’ve always felt the former, but Yen Press feels more comfortable with the latter, apparently. Does Yen Press have an aversion to labeling their product “manhwa,” or are they just preferring to use “manga” as it’s a better-known term? Am I just overthinking all this? What do you think?